WorldSport Saturday 31 May 2064
Tactics31 May 2064

“The 4-4-2 rules”

Italian Serie A’s most-used shape leads the numbers for frequency, but not points per game.

By Ollie Stroud · By the Numbers · 31 May 2064

How can a system rule the team sheets and still lose the points-per-game contest? Italian Serie A’s 4-4-2 appeared 225 times across 634 team sheets, more than any other shape, but its 1.41 points a game falls short of the 1.69 managed by Torino’s usual 5-2-2-1 DM AM.

That is a sizeable difference in return, even if the less-used shape appeared only 26 times. The 4-4-2 accounts for 35 per cent of the sheets; the 5-2-2-1 DM AM, four per cent. Popularity, then, is not the same thing as yield. Torino’s preference is a striking little outlier in a league where the familiar four-at-the-back shapes dominate.

The 4-3-3 DM Wide is next in frequency, used 193 times (30 per cent), with 1.26 points a game. Six clubs usually use it: Bari, Cittadella, Crotone, Juventus, Perugia and Udinese Calcio. The 4-2-3-1 DM AM Wide, the usual choice of ACF Fiorentina, Cosenza, Empoli Football Club, FC Internazionale Milano and S.S. Lazio, appeared 173 times (27 per cent) and returned 1.47 points a game. It is the strongest of the three most common systems by that measure.

At the other end, the 5-2-3 DM Wide was used 16 times and yielded 0.62 points a game. The 5-2-1-2 DM AM made a single appearance; there is no points-per-game figure to set beside it. The percentages are rounded, which explains why the five systems with a listed share add to 99 per cent rather than 100.

The 4-4-2’s command of the count is clear. Its lead in points is not: it sits behind both the 5-2-2-1 DM AM and the 4-2-3-1 DM AM Wide. In Italian Serie A, the most familiar answer has not been the most productive one.