Recopa Best Player
| Year | Winner | Club | Second | Third |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2053 | Gabriel Ferrari | Club Atlético River Plate | ||
| 2052 | Juan Carlos Paniagua | Club Atlético River Plate | ||
| 2051 | Anderson Guerreiro | Clube de Regatas do Flamengo | ||
| 2050 | Joaquín López | Club Atlético River Plate | ||
| 2049 | Santiago Ricci | Club Atlético Boca Juniors | ||
| 2048 | Néstor Muratori | Club Atlético Boca Juniors | ||
| 2047 | Santiago Ricci | Club Atlético Boca Juniors | ||
| 2046 | Juan Carlos Paniagua | Club Atlético River Plate | ||
| 2045 | Rodrigo Muñoz | Club Atlético River Plate | ||
| 2044 | Nicolás Testa | Club Atlético Independiente | ||
| 2043 | Carlos Borda | Club Atlético Independiente | ||
| 2042 | Bruno Palacios | Club Atlético Boca Juniors | ||
| 2041 | Juan Morel | Club Atlético Boca Juniors | ||
| 2040 | Koryan Ordenes | Colo Colo | ||
| 2039 | Matías Vásquez | Club Atlético Independiente | ||
| 2038 | Adrián Vega | Defensor Sporting Club | ||
| 2035 | Felipe Campos | Colo Colo | ||
| 2034 | None | Fluminense Football Club | ||
| 2032 | Daniel Munhoz | Santos Futebol Clube | ||
| 2029 | Leonel Fernández | Club Atlético Independiente | ||
| 2025 | Pedro | Clube de Regatas do Flamengo | ||
| 2024 | Richard Schunke | Club Independiente del Valle | ||
| 2023 | Luis Advíncula | Club Atlético Boca Juniors |
Most wins
| Juan Carlos Paniagua | 2 |
| Santiago Ricci | 2 |